The tale of 2 props

The Tale of 2 Props
I went to the Suntec Invest talk on 25 Aug 18. I preplanned my itinerary to prioritise on the choice speakers that I am interested to hear about, as well as to observe the innovations in the retail investment landscape if any . 

Anton Kriel was one of the top speakers on my list . Although I have no insight in the trading strategies he is espousing (long short portfolio) and his trading performance , his interpretation of the reality behind the financial illusion the industry is propagating is sombre and refreshing. I chanced upon the lectures by this maverick ex-Goldman trader a few years ago while I was practising dummy trading for my university project during the Cyprus crisis. Cutting through the smoke and furore generated by the online forums and news casters, I discovered fake news and conflict of interest is a very real thing indeed, and an entire industry is monetary incentivised to generate excitement and churn for the retail brokerage industry without bringing meaningful returns to the bottom line of the retail traders. His influence ironically made me shy away from the short term trading route. However,  it will be great to know more about my counterparty perspective (institutional investors) while they are trading against me. 



The gist of his 30 mins talk is only a 2 page presentation of his entire lecture. The 2 hour video I highlighted covered much more meat. 

Top down analysis based on macro themes. 
Entry and exit in tranches throughout a 1-3 month time horizon before branching out to shorter term trading or longer term buy and hold. 
Setup position limit and target risk before setting a realistic expected return. 
Not all investor like maximised return over risk / volatility. 
Dependent on fund mandate. Importance of generating a consistent and systematic process. 
Proper scheduling and proper allocation of time for trading research.
Alignment of fundamentals and technicals in order to initiate a position.

I had a short chat with Anton Kriel (within a small group). Personally, I found him to very eloquent, ruthlessly smart about trading psychology as well as immensely charismatic. Several of his key points (1-3 months timing horizon) seems to be aligned with what the professional traders I once talked with. However, based on my personal experiences with communicating with traders, as well as reading Wall street literature such as <Enron The Smartest Guys In The Room> , <Why I Left Goldman Sachs: A Wall Street Story>, and <Liar's Poker> by Michael Lewis, I can never really know if the same trader is utilising me as a counterparty and trading against me. His course fee is pretty exorbitant and he is a genius in pricing and branding his materials for a premium. Personally, I believe he is a smart trader and businessman, but due to differences in my investing / trading philosophy, I believe his ideas are great to know but not worth the premium paid.




The second proprietary trader talk I attended is by Alson chew, who is currently partnered with Adam Khoo's investing college. His knowledge of market manipulation is staggering especially in the Singapore context, and he seem to be taking pointed shots at the validity of efficient market hypothesis. Some of the key points he highlighted is as follows.
 
Do not trust order book, block trades booked by market makers. Free Market Depth by the SGX can be easily inflated / manipulated by market makers and it can give illusions of high buy /sell volumes.

Reverse engineer of trading indicators to trade against retail investors 
Print candlestick charts for distribution list to generate churn
Fallacy of momentum trading. Possible for market makers to control price and volume (premise of Dow theory)  to affect technical analysis  

Create false supply and demand volume - accumulation / divesting of existing position. 
In the short term, prices controlled by the market makers and not fundamentals 
For retail trading, understand that you are trading against your broker / counterparts and people whom move the market. They are masters of market sentiment. (offloading position) 


It has been a very enriching experience and a good place to spend the earlier half of my day. I also managed to pick up some brochures regarding to corporate bond ETFs, and had a enjoyable time exploring the 893FM as well as the investing note booth. I will look forward to blogging about similar seminar / booths in this blog while waiting for any catalyst / market changes.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A New Light

 A New Light After a hiatus from writing and picking myself up from the issues in my personal life, I decided it will be great to resume writing on a monthly frequency to connect with my inner self, and connect with like minded thinkers and writers.  Writing and investing is my passion regardless of whether I am getting paid for it. Even if no one is reading about it, writing keeps my mind sharp and discussions with others allows me to bounce off ideas with other experienced / astute investors. I am also thankful to have met new friends in person with a passion in investing in recent months, and reignite my passion in what I loved.  I will resume writing and blogging at https://caveatemptorvenditor.substack.com/
Read more

Portfolio Review 2019 - Performance Review

Image
Quantitative Measures Beta = 0.76, VaR = 8.92%, Expected Shortfall = 17.43% Overall - Time = 19.99% Performance Review for 2019 Beating the STI ETF benchmark is not difficult this year. As a market capitalized ETF, STI ETF was a late buyer in the REIT rally, which highlighted the downside of this methodology. Moreover, a lot of retail investors with larger proportion to REITS performed way better than me. My returns were also punished as I averaged down on Silverlake Axis on the recent price correction. I also sold off a percentage of STI ETF to increase my war chest instead of reallocating to US Stocks, resulting in the missing out of the Christmas rally and the year end momentum play. The S and P 500 trounced the returns of most market participants. I am not certain whether the blind money / DCA via index investors resulted into this phenomenon. There is significantly high PE stocks in the index constituents. Stocks could be simply getting more ...
Read more

Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the face

Image
  Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the face As the china central government continued their spree of popping up regulations in all areas of China economy (Minimum wages, living conditions for drivers, 996 working hours, gaming time for minors, wealth redistribution policies, Banning dancing  grannies , the list goes on), the steep decline in the HK/CN stock prices seem to be consolidating and taking a slight breather for now. Although I have stuck to the plan of disciplined averaging down from July till now, it is never easy to watch your favorite picks go cheaper as new rules are being drafted. It is never easy to stick to your convictions based on the research and thesis of the stocks you hold, and believe you are right amidst the market noise and chaos. Everybody has a plan until they get hit. Then, like a rat, they stop in fear and freeze.You can plan all you want, but you’re going to get hit – probably when you don’t expect it - and it’s going to hurt. ...
Read more